Aitabdel Salem’s 5-Month Jail Ordeal Over a $2 Bail Mix-Up

In November 2014, a New York man named Aitabdel Salem found himself locked up in one of America’s most infamous jails, Rikers Island, for five months. The reason? A shocking mix-up: nobody told him his bail was just $2. This story, uncovered by Phacts, reveals a troubling flaw in the justice system, where a small oversight led to a man losing months of his life over an amount most people could find in their pocket. Let’s dive into the details of this heartbreaking case, exploring who Aitabdel Salem was, what led to his arrest, how the $2 bail mistake happened, and what it means for the bigger picture.

Who Was Aitabdel Salem?

Aitabdel Salem was a 41-year-old Algerian immigrant living in Queens, New York, at the time of his arrest. He was an ordinary man, working to make a living in a bustling city. Like many immigrants, he faced challenges adjusting to life in the U.S., including navigating a complex legal system that wasn’t always clear to him. Salem’s story isn’t just about one man’s misfortune—it’s a window into how the justice system can fail people who don’t have the resources or knowledge to fight back.

The Arrest That Started It All

On November 21, 2014, Salem walked into a Zara clothing store in Manhattan’s Flatiron District. According to police, he tried to steal a coat. When an officer confronted him, things escalated. Salem was accused of attacking the officer, a serious charge that landed him in hot water. He was arrested and taken to Rikers Island, a jail known for its harsh conditions, gang violence, and history of corruption. His bail was initially set at $25,000—an amount far beyond what most people, including Salem, could afford.

At this point, Salem’s situation looked grim. Rikers Island isn’t a place anyone wants to stay for long. The jail sits on an island once used as a landfill and pig farm, and its reputation for brutality is well-documented. For Salem, the high bail meant he was stuck there, waiting for his case to move forward.

A Glimmer of Hope: Bail Reduced to $2

Just a week after his arrest, on November 28, 2014, something surprising happened. Prosecutors couldn’t gather enough evidence to indict Salem on the assault charge. Without an indictment, the judge ordered his release. But there was a catch: Salem still faced two minor charges from earlier that year for allegedly tampering with a subway card machine. These were small offenses, nothing like the assault charge. Because they were so minor, the judge set bail at just $1 for each charge, totaling $2.

Two dollars. The price of a coffee, a bus ride, or a slice of pizza in New York. It was an amount Salem could have easily paid to walk free. But here’s where the story takes a devastating turn: nobody told him about the $2 bail. Not his lawyer, not the court, not the corrections officers at Rikers. Salem, believing his bail was still $25,000, stayed locked up, unaware that freedom was just two dollars away.

Why Didn’t Anyone Tell Him?

The blame for this oversight falls largely on Salem’s lawyer at the time, Stephen Pokart from the Legal Aid Society. Legal Aid provides free lawyers to people who can’t afford one, but like many public defenders, Pokart was likely overworked with a heavy caseload. Salem’s new attorneys, Glenn Hardy and Theodore Goldbergh, later argued that Pokart failed to do his job. They said he never informed Salem about the reduced bail or what was happening in his case.

Salem himself was stunned when he learned the truth. “He was shocked and dismayed and frustrated that his case was mishandled,” Hardy said in a court hearing. Imagine sitting in a dangerous jail, thinking you’re stuck because you can’t pay thousands of dollars, only to find out later you could have walked out for pocket change. The frustration must have been overwhelming.

But was it just Pokart’s fault? The system itself played a role. Courts and jails are busy, chaotic places. Paperwork gets lost, communication breaks down, and defendants like Salem—especially those who don’t speak perfect English or know how the system works—can slip through the cracks. Salem repeatedly asked corrections officers about his case, but they either didn’t know or didn’t bother to help. His pleas went ignored.

Life Inside Rikers Island

While the $2 bail miscommunication kept Salem trapped, he endured five months in Rikers Island, from November 2014 to April 2015. Rikers is notorious for its brutal environment. Inmates face overcrowding, violence from other prisoners, and mistreatment from guards. For someone like Salem, who was there over a minor issue, the experience was likely terrifying.

Every day, he woke up in a cramped cell, surrounded by the sounds of shouting and clanging metal. Meals were basic, often unappetizing. He had to stay alert to avoid trouble with other inmates. And all the while, he had no idea that $2 could end his ordeal. The mental toll of this must have been immense—feeling abandoned by the system, unsure when or if he’d get out.

How Salem Finally Got Out

In April 2015, a prison chaplain stepped in and paid Salem’s $2 bail. It’s unclear why the chaplain got involved—maybe Salem’s questions finally reached someone who cared enough to check his file. Whatever the reason, the chaplain’s small act of kindness set Salem free after five long months. But his troubles didn’t end there.

Back in Jail: A Missed Court Date

Just a few weeks after his release, in May 2015, Salem was arrested again. This time, it was for missing a court date related to the original assault charge. His new lawyers argued he never knew about the hearing because the letter notifying him was marked “return to sender.” Salem wasn’t trying to skip court—he simply didn’t get the memo. But the judge didn’t buy it, and Salem was sent back to Rikers, this time with a much higher bail of $30,000.

This second arrest added insult to injury. Salem had already lost five months of his life over a $2 mix-up. Now, another miscommunication—lost mail—landed him back in jail. His lawyers fought to clear his name, pointing out that defendants have a right to trust the system to keep them informed. But the damage was done.

Salem Fights Back: Filing a Lawsuit

By 2017, Salem had had enough. He filed a lawsuit against New York City and the Legal Aid Society, seeking justice for the months he lost. The lawsuit claimed that Salem “implored corrections officers” to tell him what was happening with his case, but they ignored him. It also accused his former lawyer of failing to communicate the $2 bail. Salem’s new attorneys argued that the city and Legal Aid were responsible for the systemic failures that kept him locked up.

The lawsuit was a bold move. Suing the city and a powerful organization like Legal Aid isn’t easy, especially for someone with limited resources. But Salem’s case struck a chord. It highlighted how small mistakes in the justice system can have huge consequences for regular people.

The Bigger Picture: A Broken Bail System

Salem’s story isn’t just about one man—it’s a symptom of a larger problem. The bail system in the U.S. has long been criticized for punishing people who can’t afford to pay. While Salem’s $2 bail was unusually low, many others sit in jail for months or years because they can’t pay hundreds or thousands of dollars. These are people who haven’t been convicted of a crime—they’re presumed innocent but locked up anyway.

Take Kalief Browder, another Rikers inmate. At age 16, he was jailed for three years on a $3,000 bail for allegedly stealing a backpack. Unable to pay, he endured horrific conditions before his case was dropped. Tragically, Browder took his own life after his release, haunted by the trauma. Stories like his and Salem’s show how the bail system can ruin lives, especially for people with low income.

Phacts dug into this issue because it matters. The bail system is meant to ensure people show up for court, not to trap them in jail over misunderstandings or poverty. Salem’s case exposes how miscommunication, overworked lawyers, and a lack of accountability can turn a minor issue into a major injustice.

What Happened to Salem?

The outcome of Salem’s lawsuit and his later legal battles isn’t fully clear. Some reports suggest he was still in jail in 2017, facing the $30,000 bail. Others indicate he was acquitted of the bail-jumping charge after his lawyers proved he never got the court notice. What is clear is that Salem’s life was forever changed by those five months in Rikers. He lost time, peace of mind, and trust in the system.

Lessons from Salem’s Story

Aitabdel Salem’s ordeal teaches us several hard truths. First, communication in the justice system needs to improve. Defendants must be clearly informed about their bail and court dates, especially those who don’t speak fluent English or can’t afford private lawyers. Second, public defenders need better support. Overworked attorneys like Pokart are set up to fail, and their clients pay the price. Finally, the bail system itself needs reform. No one should sit in jail for months over $2—or any amount they can’t pay for minor charges.

Phacts is committed to shining a light on stories like this. We believe in uncovering the truth and pushing for a fairer world. Salem’s case isn’t just a news story—it’s a call to action to fix a system that lets people fall through the cracks.

Why This Story Matters to Phacts

At Phacts, we’re all about getting to the bottom of things. We don’t just report the news—we dig into the human side of it. Aitabdel Salem’s story hit us hard because it’s about more than a $2 bail. It’s about a man who was let down by the very system meant to protect him. It’s about the countless others who face similar struggles every day. By sharing this story, we hope to spark conversations and inspire change.

Join the Phacts Movement

Aitabdel Salem’s story is a reminder that the truth matters, and so does justice. At Phacts, we’re on a mission to uncover stories that make a difference. Want to be part of it? Here’s how you can get involved:

• Subscribe to Phacts: Sign up for our newsletter at phactsblog.com to get the latest stories delivered to your inbox. Stay informed about issues that affect real people.
• Share This Story: Spread the word about Salem’s case. Post this article on social media, email it to a friend, or talk about it with your community. Awareness is the first step to change.
• Support Bail Reform: Learn about organizations working to fix the bail system. Groups like The Bail Project are helping people get out of jail and pushing for fairer laws.
• Tell Us Your Story: Have you or someone you know faced a similar injustice? Reach out to Phacts at phactsblog.com/contact. Your story could inspire others.

Together, we can demand a justice system that works for everyone, not just the wealthy or well-connected. Let’s keep digging for the truth with Phacts.

• ShareCopied to clipboard